8 Items Not to Buy from Pottery Barn (That You Can Buy from Amazon for Less)
We all love the timeless, elevated look of Pottery Barn — the cozy textures, neutral palettes, and classic furniture pieces feel like a warm hug. But what we don’t always love? The price tag.
The good news? You can get the same beautiful Pottery Barn aesthetic without the high-end price. Amazon is packed with lookalike items that give you that designer feel — often for half the price or less. Below, we’re sharing 8 Pottery Barn-style pieces you should skip — and what to buy from Amazon instead.
This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you if you shop through our links—thank you for supporting our blog!
1. Ceramic Lamp
Pottery Barn Price: $200+
Amazon Lookalike: Monarch Table Lamp
This contemporary beige ceramic table lamp brings understated elegance to any space — and it’s a fraction of the cost of similar styles at Pottery Barn. With its soft glow and neutral palette, it works beautifully in coastal, modern farmhouse, or minimalist decor schemes. An affordable way to elevate your lighting game!
Why We Love It: It gives off serious Pottery Barn vibes — without the price tag.
2. Throw Blankets
Pottery Barn Price: $129
Amazon Lookalike: SAMIAH LUXE Beige White Chunky Knit Blanket Throw
Soft, oversized throws are a Pottery Barn staple, but this Amazon version offers the same cozy texture and comes in more color options.
🛋️ Why We Love It: Gorgeous drape, warm enough for chilly evenings, and machine washable.
3. Pillow Covers
Pottery Barn Price: $60+ per cover
Amazon Lookalike: MIULEE Pack of 2 Velvet Throw Pillow Covers
PB’s pillows are beautiful, but you can mix-and-match luxe velvet, boucle, or linen pillow covers on Amazon for a curated look that doesn’t cost $200 per couch.
🛋️ Why We Love It: Budget-friendly enough to switch up seasonally.
4. Farmhouse Mirrors
Pottery Barn Price: $399
Amazon Lookalike: BEAUTYPEAK Arched Wall Mirror
Looking to elevate your bathroom, entryway, or bedroom without spending a fortune? This BEAUTYPEAK arch mirror delivers high-end style at a budget-friendly price. With its clean, curved silhouette and sleek black metal frame, it’s a perfect dupe for similar Pottery Barn mirrors — but at a fraction of the cost.
At 24"x36", it’s generously sized to make a statement without overwhelming your space. Whether you're finishing off a modern farmhouse bathroom or adding a touch of drama to a hallway, this mirror brings instant polish and light to any room.
Why We Love It: Looks like a $400 mirror from Pottery Barn — but it’s under $100 on Amazon.
5. Iron Candle Holders
Pottery Barn Price: $49+ each
Amazon Lookalike: Stonebriar 7" Black Cast Iron Metal Taper Candle Holder
Looking for that moody, minimalist candle holder vibe you see in all the Pottery Barn and Studio McGee catalogs? This set of black cast iron taper holders from Stonebriar delivers that same sculptural, high-end look — but for under $30 on Amazon.
The sleek black finish and classic silhouette make these a go-to styling piece for mantels, dining tables, console displays, or open shelving. Whether you're creating a cozy holiday tablescape or elevating everyday décor, these candle holders add instant style and texture.
Why We Love It: They mimic the weighty, matte black metal holders you’d pay triple for at designer stores.
6. Wood Accent Stool
Pottery Barn Price: $299
Amazon Lookalike: VaeFae Teak Accent Stool
Create a spa-like sanctuary in your bathroom — without the Pottery Barn price tag. This VaeFae teak shower bench brings natural warmth, functionality, and high-end design to any bathroom or walk-in shower. Made from 100% solid teak wood, it’s water-resistant, sturdy, and built to last.
Its clean, minimal lines and warm wood tones give off those luxe, coastal-inspired vibes you’d expect to find in a Pottery Barn catalog — but at a fraction of the price. Bonus: the built-in shelf offers extra storage for towels, bath accessories, or spa essentials.
Why We Love It: Works as a plant stand, side table, or even a spa-style bath seat.
7. Rattan Pendant Lights
Pottery Barn Price: $499
Amazon Lookalike: Boho Banmboo Large Pendant Light
Get that beachy, boho look with natural light fixtures that cast the same warm glow — but leave room in your budget for other decor.
🛋️ Why We Love It: Instantly elevates a kitchen island, entryway, or nursery.
8. Dining Chair Sets
Pottery Barn Price: $800+ for 2 chairs
Amazon Lookalike: CIMOTA Upholstered Dining Chairs (Set of 2)
You don’t have to spend a fortune to get that upholstered Pottery Barn vibe. These chairs are sturdy, stylish, and incredibly well-reviewed.
Why We Love It: Modern farmhouse meets mid-century, and your guests will never guess the price.
Final Thoughts
Pottery Barn style is iconic, but you don’t need to blow your budget to get the look. These Amazon finds are designer-inspired, incredibly affordable, and often just as durable. Whether you're styling a living room, bedroom, or entryway, these swaps help you build a beautifully curated home — without the sticker shock.
🛒 Pro Tip: Most of these Amazon finds are eligible for Prime shipping and returns, so you can try them risk-free.
